Risk adjustment for measuring patient outcomes author. This edited book describes concepts and techniques for risk adjustment in measurement of health outcomes. The hhshcc risk adjustment model for individual and small group markets under the affordable care act. Success measures evaluation tools for community development and health 3 background why the tools were developed across the united states, affordable housing and community development practitioners have come to recognize the important links between their programs and the health of the people and communities they serve.
Outcomes are always multidimensional and should include the health results most relevant to patients 4. This book is a comprehensive guide to the issues raised by risk adjustment, including the pros and cons of different. As the emphasis in health reform shifts to valuebased payments, especially through multipayer initiatives supported by the u. Recently siemens healthcare visited our facility to highlight hoag orthopedic institute as a goldstandard for how to measure health outcomes and to implement resulting findings in clinical practice. Healthcare organizations need to begin treating data as a powerful asset and be willing to invest in a strategy for leveraging it in order to address these issues and realize the triple aim douglas laney, author of 3d data management. Measurement must include initial conditionsrisk factors to allow for risk adjustment 5. The study population consisted of adult patients receiving treatment for common mental health disorders. Risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes, fourth edition by md,lisa iezzoni and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes 4th. The challenge in using outcomes as a measure of healthcare quality is to account for the unmodifiable factors so that variations in outcomes between providers are attributable to the processes of stroke care and more accurately reflect the quality of care provided. Use of risk adjustment in setting budgets and measuring.
With highvolume providers, observed outcome rates are less likely to be skewed by outliers than are the rates of lower volume providers 28. To allow direct comparison of bloodstream infection bsi rates between hospitals for performance measurement, observed rates need to be risk adjusted according to the types of patients cared for by the hospital. For example, a clinical diagnosis of heart failure captured by a data abstractor from an electronic health record may appear important in a registry but will not reliably identify patients with or without meaningful left ventricular dysfunction. Conclusions regarding the minimum requirements for riskadjustment data when. Performance measurement for health system improvement. Outcomes should reflect the full cycle of care for the condition 3. How can we actually say and prove to an organisation that what we are doing within the risk management field is actually making a difference and. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes, 3rd.
Outcomes measurement and risk adjustment are statistical procedures that rely on large sample sizes to produce risk estimates and outcome interpretations that are trustworthy. Risk adjustment is used in all major public programs offering health coverage in the united statesincluding medicare advantage ma, medicare part d, and state medicaid managed care programs. Risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes by lisa. Risk adjustment of ischemic stroke outcomes for comparing. The outcome was selfreported symptom level at posttest. Overview of risk adjustment and outcome measures for home. The movement to measure medical care quality has been accelerating, spurred on by evidence of poor quality of care and trials of interventions to improve care. Appropriate measurement of quality of care is an essential aspect of improving the quality of care, yet some quality measures may be influenced by patients attributes unrelated to quality of care. Using riskadjusted outcomes to assess clinical practice. As an integrated care unit, the institute specializes in orthopedics and is able to control the clinical quality along the care processes. The united kingdom is no different in this respect, and the past 20 years have seen the introduction of numerous initiatives aimed at improving the efficiency of the nhs. The aim of this paper is to compare singlelevel and multilevel regression analysis to obtain riskadjusted outcomes from mental health care providers.
At that time, payers and researchers were concerned with risk adjustment primarily as a tool for hospital payment and for assessing hospital performance. The importance of risk adjustment for measuring and reporting healthcare outcomes in the new healthcare environment, where quality and outcomes are increasingly linked to reimbursement and public reporting initiatives, you face several challenges to keeping the money flowing and your ratings high. Although the health care financing administration had ceased issuing medicare riskadjusted mortality rate reports, several other hospital. The risk adjustment methodology, using a predictive model developed specifically for each measure, compensates for differences in the patient population served by different home health agencies. Exploring the use of machine learning for risk adjustment. Reasons for risk adjustment, risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes, 3rd ed. Risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes 4th. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes, fourth edition aupha hap book. How to adjust for casemix when comparing outcomes across. Publication date 1994 topics health risk assessment, health risk assessment, outcome assessment medical care, outcome assessment health care, risk factors, decision support techniques, delivery of health care, models, statistical publisher.
Measuring risk management outcomes hello, in this session i want to talk about the thing that a lot of risk management people struggle with and that is the measurement of risk management outcomes. The importance of risk adjustment for measuring and. Scheduled to publish in august, risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes, third edition, by lisa iezzoni, examines how risk adjustment controls for the intrinsic health risks that patients bring to their healthcare encounters. However, attribute data on all individual patients are often unavailable and hospitallevel risk adjustment needs to be done using indirect indicator variables of patient case mix. Measuring outcomes in healthcare orthopedic care in. Lisa iezzoni and colleagues produced the first edition of risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes nearly 10 years ago.
Pdf an empirically derived risk adjustment model is useful in distinguishing among facilities in their quality of care. The first goal of the present study was to describe the risk adjustment method we applied to routine outcome monitoring data in the netherlands. Download risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes, fourth.
Standardize outcome measures to enable comparison and learning. Risk stratification, risk adjustment, and other risks. Medicaid innovation, and with the increasing availability of statewide allpayer claims databases, the need for an allpayer, wholepopulation approach to facilitate the reporting of utilization, cost, and quality measures has grown. Challenges in risk adjustment for hospital and provider outcomes assessment article in circulation 54. Riskadjustment is a critical tool in the evaluation of health care quality. She is the editor of risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes 1997. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes. Risk adjustment for performance measurement l i s a i. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes by iezzoni, lisa i. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app.
The reporting of clinical outcomes is essential for quality improvement, patient choice and accountability, all of which are becoming increasingly important within healthcare systems across the world. Risk adjustment models were developed using single and multilevel. Save up to 80% by choosing the etextbook option for isbn. Besides mortality, other measure outcomes that are commonly riskadjusted include.
When it comes to measuring the outcomes of risk management, this is the best you can hope for. The fourth edition of risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes presents the fundamental principles and concepts of risk adjustment for comparing outcomes of care and explains why risk adjustment is a critical tool for measuring quality and setting reimbursement rates. Kautter j, pope gc, ingber m, freeman s, patterson l, cohen m, et al. An application in va long term care article pdf available in american journal of medical quality 164 july 2001 with 469 reads. Reproduced with the authors permission from paladin risk management services. Hillson, md, msc university of minnesota medical school description. Risk adjustment is a particularly important topic at this point in history because of its role in the major health reforms envisioned under the. With thyroidectomyspecific variables indicates hospital rank when thyroidectomyspecific variables were available for risk adjustment. Benchmarking clinical performance by comparing diabetes health outcomes across healthcare providers drives quality improvement. Riskadjusted outcome measures are identified in the home health outcome measures table pdf that is available in the downloads section below. A meaningful comparison of clinical outcomes of mental health care providers requires risk adjustment of case mix variables that affect treatment outcome. This book is a comprehensive guide to the issues raised by risk adjustment, including the pros and cons of different data sources, the validity and reliability of risk. Risk adjustment is increasingly recognized as crucial to re.
For many years, health care providers have worked to collect socalled patientreported. Measuring and improving the value of hospital care. Controlling data volume, velocity, and variety, is now tackling. Riskadjustment of diabetes health outcomes improves the. It also includes highlevel treatment variables to allow stratification of outcomes by major treatment types, a data dictionary and scoring guides for patientreported outcomes. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes 4th edition by iezzoni, lisa i. Its aim is to level the playing field so that providers serving different patients can be meaningfully compared johnson, 2003.
Rosen a1, wu j, chang bh, berlowitz d, rakovski c, ash a, moskowitz m. Covariates used for risk adjustment may be subjective too, even for common cardiovascular conditions. Improved hospitallevel risk adjustment for surveillance. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes 3rd edition. Risk adjusted outcome measures are identified in the home health outcome measures table pdf that is available in the downloads section below. Outcome measures adjust for patient characteristics that exist prior to the. Like its predecessors, the fourth edition of risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes presents the fundamental principles and concepts of risk adjustment for comparing outcomes of care and explains why risk adjustment is a critical tool for measuring quality and setting reimbursement rates. It contains 11 chapters covering dimensions of risk, sources of riskrelated data, how to develop and assess riskadjustment methods for various outcomes, and comparison of. Data sources for outcomes measurement are described, and the concept of risk adjustment. Risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes third. However, these outcomes are challenging to measure in a consistent, efficient, and. For example, risk adjustment could be used to ensure a fair comparison of the performance of two. Healthcare systems in countries throughout the developed world are faced with the problem of limiting the growth in spending on health services while ensuring that their populations have access to appropriate care.
Risk adjustment for mental and substance use conditions has lagged behind other areas of medicine, but model. Challenges in risk adjustment for hospital and provider. Risk adjustment of selfreported clinical outcomes in. Comparisons of healthcare measures across regions of england are already freely available through the national health service nhs atlas of variation in healthcare,1 and individual cardiac. Complexity in measuring quality and outcome in healthcare is compounded by deciding who should set the criteria for quality, how these criteria are set, and whether the criteria are empirical or normative i. Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes, 3rd edition. The third edition of risk adjustment for measuring health care outcome will be a valuable reference both for developers and consumers of risk adjusted outcome information, and it may help to tilt the balance towards more valid and ultimately more useful information on health care quality and efficiency. Download here risk adjustment for measuring healthcare outcomes third edition free books. Hospitals circles are ranked by better lower rank number to worse higher rank number performance for each of the 6 studied outcomes. Iezzoni is professor of medicine at the harvard medical school and the beth israel deaconess medical center, division of general medicine and primary care.
491 494 995 665 1180 1637 385 390 528 1083 1550 1102 1162 882 58 270 686 926 1296 1126 1414 346 1170 18 941 11 641 223 539 953 73 1309 1477 1166 328